
For most of my life, I have been intrigued by the question of what it means to belong to the land. Is belonging determined by where we are born, by our ancestry, by the culture that raises us? Or is it something that develops through relationship?
This question has become increasingly important to me as I reflect on the meaning of Indigeneity. One academic definition I resonate with says that Indigenous “refers to people and communities with longstanding and/or continuous connection to the land, whose cultures and spiritual practices are informed by and tied to the land.”
Today, it seems ever clearer how vital that connection to the land is: knowing how to work with nature and flow with it. We all know about the catastrophic consequences of forgetting or ignoring this relationship: extreme weather, degradation of the soil, loss of biodiversity, and what many scientists describe as the sixth mass extinction.
I feel that when we look broadly, with the eyes of the heart rather than through the lens of shortsightedness and greed, we can recognize that the “civilized” world has much to relearn from Indigenous societies. Perhaps most importantly, we need to remember how to live in reciprocity: not taking more than the Earth can offer, and finding ways to replenish and restore what we harvest.
At the same time, I do not romanticize Indigenous communities. Like any human society, they have their own complexities, wounds, and contradictions, which have at times given rise to internal conflict and even warfare between neighboring peoples.
My own journey with these questions began in Chile. As a child, I felt part of the valley and mountains where I grew up. There was never much doubt about belonging to my birthplace or to the society around me in Santiago.
Later, in my youth, as I learned more about the original peoples of Chile, I began pondering the diversity of my own roots. For the first time, I felt somewhat split in two and became curious about my European ancestry and what it meant to belong to a land shaped by so many different histories.
At twenty-one, I landed in the hippie scene of California and, strangely enough, I had never felt more at home. For many years after that, I lived as if I were simply a native of planet Earth. Home was wherever my heart was.
This changed in my early thirties, when I found myself in deep emotional distress and suddenly longed for “my land and my people.” I returned to Chile and recognized, in a much more visceral way, the bond I had with the land that had birthed me. It felt almost like an umbilical cord pulling me home.
That sense of belonging deepened even further when I began working with the land itself. I became a caretaker of sixty acres, co-creating with the local community, with the seasons, the soil, the water, the trees, and the animals.
Over time, I began to understand that belonging to a place is not only about where we were born or ancestry. It is also about relationship. It is about learning to listen to a land, to care for it, to receive from it without simply taking, and to give something back.
Perhaps this is where my understanding of Indigeneity becomes most personal. I recognize something deeply true in the Indigenous understanding that land is not merely property or a resource. It is part of who we are. And the more I work with the land, the more I feel that belonging is something we inherit, but also something we cultivate and practice—through reciprocity, responsibility, gratitude, and care.
What has been your experience of belonging? Does it have to do with ancestry, community, relationship with the land, or something else?
With love,
Marcela Lobos
7 Comments
I relate to what your saying, I was born in México and raised in the USA. My Grandmother buried my belly button in the soil .And when I go back 2 or 3 times in a year I feel so coneccted to my roots and the land there.I live in Texas now ,I was raised in California. In my town there’s a construction of community there Im surrounded by mountains and its beautiful, I will move there in the near future. Thank you for sharing your story, I send you a hug from my heart. 🙏🏻🤍🪶
Hola Marcela! En esta vida nací en Buenos Aires en un barrio no del centro de la ciudad. Vivo desde hace años en otro barrio, ahora en la ciudad. Mis más fuertes y bellas experiencias de pertenencia han sido y sigen siendo durante mis contactos con La Tierra: en el Sur, Norte, Este y Oeste del país. La ciudad de Buenos Aires tiene muchísimos espacios verdes y en ellos vuelvo a contactarME con La Tierra. Abrazar un árbol, caminar la tierra descalzo, sentarme sobre las raíces de añosos árboles, acariciar con la mirada las flores… TODO ESO ES ENERGÍA VITAL PARA MI. Gracias por el espacio Marcela. Con Amor, Oscar
Hi Marcela,
Thank you for that woderful writings.
For my part since my early age, I am now73, I always had the intuiton that it is importent to live and stay where you are born. Not knowing why, and not doing as one of my brothers who left Luxembourg for living in Australia.
Until the age of 25 I lived whit my parents in the city of Luxembourg. After my studies, where I have been in different contries, I bought an old farmhouse with 20 ares for gardening in a little village callde Ernzen.
But only since a few years, I do gardening.
Today I get more and more connected to nature, the plants, trees, flowers, soil ….and the more I get connected, the more I get blessed by mama Gaia.
Though today I can understand where my intuiton is guiding me.
I am soo greatful for the blessings from great Spirit and mama Gaia.
Blessingsto you and Alberto.
I hope this stays short so I don’t bore anyone. One of my biggest dilemmas in life was feeling like I did not belong anywhere (ancestry, community etc)….No connection with birth family, put in foster care (many homes til I was 5 of different ancestry, community no sense of direct relationship or belongness with anything but nature. My birth family was Irish/Scottish and Native but neer met them, my foster family were Swedish/Norwegian growing up in an English/French neghbourhood. Religon was Catholic/Protestant and I didn’t even belong to any of them due to family background. The only place I seemed to belong was in nature with the woods and forests, gardens and animals etc.. Just not belonging in any human community or ancestry. When I left home at 16, I just wanted to go search the world to see if I actually ‘belonged’ anywhere. Twenty years later, it seemed to me that I actually belonged everywhere. I still have my moments of not ‘fitting in” and yet I still belong anywhere for which I am so ver grateful. Thank you Marcela for your and your husband’s teachings…..they hhave helped more that you can every realize.
Liebe Marcela und Lesende
ich wohne seit meiner Kindheit hier in Ipsach am Bielersee in der Natur mit Pferden. Nun hat sich unsere Tochter entschlossen den Pensionstall aufzugeben und unsere Pferde in einem grösseren Stall unterzubringen wo die ganze Infrastruktur schon bereitet ist. Nun sind wir bereit zu verkaufen. Es fühlt sich richtig an jedoch weiss ich noch nicht wo ich mich so richtig wohl fühlen werde wie hier. Es wird sich zeigen. Doch die Freiheit ruft, das weiss ich. Endlich Reisen und neue Kulturen kennen lernen.
Es gibt ja überall Pferde auf der Welt. Wenn ich mich verbinde mit allen Elementen fühle ich mich zu Hause.
Dear Marcela,
You’ve really given me something to reflect on. ❤️
I would say that my experience of belonging is deeply connected to people.
In the beginning, it was my grandparents and their home, where I spent so much of my time. In winter, my grandfather would light the fireplace, and we would often sit together by the fire while my grandmother baked cakes. I can still smell them! ❤️
They were both passionate about sports, so we spent countless hours watching all kinds of games and competitions on TV, especially the Olympic Games. We would even wake up in the middle of the night to watch them if they were taking place in a different time zone. It was our little tradition.
When they passed away, that world disappeared in a way, but it never really left me. It still lives within me.
And I find myself carrying those little traditions forward, creating similar moments and feelings with my own family , my husband and daughter. And yes, I even have a fireplace! 😊
So today, my sense of belonging is deeply rooted in my husband and daughter, in the moments we share, the memories we create, and the warmth of simply being together.
With love,
Trešnja ❤️
In Los Angeles, in the 1950s I would go exploring on my bicycle. I found what I called my secret place. It was little cave in a hill below a sanitarium. I can still remember the smell of wild onions and the damp earth where I sat there. Now, approaching 80 years, I’m living in a beautiful green forest in the Ozarks in Arkansas, off the grid, with my two kitties, completely content and always amazed that I am here and ever so grateful.